Wines from Italy
| Price | KWG Score | ||
| 1. Carnasciale 2021 "Il Caberlot Sommelleria" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $236 | 98 (4 reviews) |  |
| 2. Petrolo 2021 "Galatrona" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $150 | 97 (6 reviews) | |
| 3. Sette Ponti 2022 "Oreno" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $142 | 95.2 (5 reviews) | |
| 4. Mauritson 2021 "Loam Suther" Cabernet Sauvignon | $100 | 94 (2 reviews) | |
| 5. Podere Sapaio 2019 "Sapaio" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $94 | 93.7 (2 reviews) | |
| 6. Il Poggione 2017 "Brunello di Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $100 | 93.7 (6 reviews) | |
| 7. Nozzole 2022 "Chianti Classico Riserva" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $26 | 93.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 8. Tenuta San Guido 2022 "Guidalberto" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $71 | 93.5 (4 reviews) | |
| 9. Agricola Punica 2021 "Barrua" Italy (Other Regional Reds) | $45 | 93 (1 review) | |
| 10. Planeta 2020 "Eruzione 1614 Nerello Mascalese" Italy (Other Regional Reds) | $49 | 93 (4 reviews) | |
| 11. Produttori del Barbaresco 2019 "Barbaresco" Italian (Piedmont) Red | $54 | 93 (6 reviews) | |
| 12. Silvio Nardi 2019 "Brunello di Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $95 | 93 (5 reviews) | |
| 13. Peter Zemmer 2022 "Lagrein Riserva Furggl" Italy (Other Regional Reds) | $38 | 92.8 (3 reviews) | |
| 14. Biserno 2022 "Il Pino di Biserno" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $60 | 92.8 (6 reviews) | |
| 15. Peter Zemmer 2022 "Riserva Giatl Pinot Grigio" Italian White | $46 | 92.7 (2 reviews) | |
| 16. Muri Gries 2023 "Lagrein" Italy (Other Regional Reds) | $20 | 92.6 (3 reviews) | |
| 17. Nozzole 2023 "Chianti Classico Villa Nozzole" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $25 | 92.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 18. Cabreo 2021 "Il Borgo" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $70 | 92.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 19. Paolo Manzone 2019 "Barolo Cru Meriame" Italian (Piedmont) Red | $80 | 92.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 20. Frescobaldi 2018 "CastelGiocondo Brunello di Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $70 | 92.3 (7 reviews) | |
